About this rating

This rating is based on whether Angels love it enough to buy this vintage again. You can also see how this wine rated for previous vintages.

Vintage

% Would Buy It Again

2023

84% of 57

2024

85% of 68

2022

71% of 124

2021

Too early to tell

2020

85% of 185

2019

Too early to tell

2018

89% of 276

2007

Too early to tell

2015

82% of 118

2017

85% of 169

2016

86% of 158

2005

75% of 106

2013

81% of 222

2006

84% of 61

Montvalley Hunter Valley Reserve Semillon 2023

Angels save money compared to Market Price...

Our market price is what you’d actually have to pay for this wine at an old-fashioned retail store.

It’s based on the price of similarly rated benchmark bottles on the market.

We test these market prices every vintage with blind tasting panels, to make sure they’re honest and accurate.

If you buy one of our wines and disagree with the Angel Price, we’ll add a credit to your account.

  • Brokenwood Bainton's Semillon

    $40.00

    Vintage Cellars

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Tyrrell's Belford Semillon

    $28.99

    Dan Murphy's

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Montvalley Hunter Valley Reserve Semillon 2023

    $28.99

    Naked Wines

    (As of 31/08/2023)

$28.99

Angels Angel Price

$14.49

Angels save money compared to Market Price...

Our market price is what you’d actually have to pay for this wine at an old-fashioned retail store.

It’s based on the price of similarly rated benchmark bottles on the market.

We test these market prices every vintage with blind tasting panels, to make sure they’re honest and accurate.

If you buy one of our wines and disagree with the Angel Price, we’ll add a credit to your account.

  • Brokenwood Bainton's Semillon

    $40.00

    Vintage Cellars

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Tyrrell's Belford Semillon

    $28.99

    Dan Murphy's

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Montvalley Hunter Valley Reserve Semillon 2023

    $28.99

    Naked Wines

    (As of 31/08/2023)

$28.99

Angels Angel Price

$14.49

Never Miss Out
Never Miss Out

Guarantee yourself first dibs of the next vintage (and every vintage thereafter) by popping your name on the reserve list today. There are no tie-ins or commitments, you can take your name off the list at any point. We'll email you a week or two before the wine arrives, then pop your wines in the post (unless you tell us not to). There's absolutely nothing to pay today. You simply settle up when we ship you the wine. Please click here for a full list of FAQS.

Guarantee yourself first dibs of the next vintage (and every vintage thereafter) by popping your name on the reserve list. Nothing to pay today!

50 people have already reserved their case

We've found the perfect replacement…
Rate this wine
We've found the perfect replacement…
Montvalley Hunter Valley Reserve Semillon 2023
Angels save money compared to Market Price...

Our market price is what you’d actually have to pay for this wine at an old-fashioned retail store.

It’s based on the price of similarly rated benchmark bottles on the market.

We test these market prices every vintage with blind tasting panels, to make sure they’re honest and accurate.

If you buy one of our wines and disagree with the Angel Price, we’ll add a credit to your account.

  • Brokenwood Bainton's Semillon

    $40.00

    Vintage Cellars

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Tyrrell's Belford Semillon

    $28.99

    Dan Murphy's

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Montvalley Hunter Valley Reserve Semillon 2023

    $28.99

    Naked Wines

    (As of 31/08/2023)

$28.99

Angels Angel Price

$14.49

Angels save money compared to Market Price...

Our market price is what you’d actually have to pay for this wine at an old-fashioned retail store.

It’s based on the price of similarly rated benchmark bottles on the market.

We test these market prices every vintage with blind tasting panels, to make sure they’re honest and accurate.

If you buy one of our wines and disagree with the Angel Price, we’ll add a credit to your account.

  • Brokenwood Bainton's Semillon

    $40.00

    Vintage Cellars

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Tyrrell's Belford Semillon

    $28.99

    Dan Murphy's

    (As of 07/07/2022)

  • Montvalley Hunter Valley Reserve Semillon 2023

    $28.99

    Naked Wines

    (As of 31/08/2023)

$28.99

Angels Angel Price

$14.49

Never Miss Out
Never Miss Out

Guarantee yourself first dibs of the next vintage (and every vintage thereafter) by popping your name on the reserve list today. There are no tie-ins or commitments, you can take your name off the list at any point. We'll email you a week or two before the wine arrives, then pop your wines in the post (unless you tell us not to). There's absolutely nothing to pay today. You simply settle up when we ship you the wine. Please click here for a full list of FAQS.

Guarantee yourself first dibs of the next vintage (and every vintage thereafter) by popping your name on the reserve list. Nothing to pay today!

50 people have already reserved their case

We've found the perfect replacement…
Rate this wine

Customer comments

You can drag and drop a file here…

…or choose a file from your computer
Add
Madelaine Santini Angel

5 months ago

Bit too lime-y and sour, maybe would've been more to my taste with age.

(latest reply 5 months ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

Yes, Semillon is fresh and zesty when young, maturing with biscuity, malt, honey and toast richness which perhaps you'd prefer.

I'll have Naked refund this bottle and perhaps you can try something else of ours.

Cheers, John

Like 5 months ago
Liz Whiteman Angel

7 months ago

Easy drinking

(latest reply 7 months ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

Thanks for the review Liz and really pleased you enjoyed this one.

Cheers, John
ps remember to follow us so you are the first to hear about our new releases or special offers.

Like 7 months ago
Bree Silvestri Angel

10 months ago

Light and a little sweet, easily enjoyable for day drinking haha ❤️

(latest reply 9 months ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

No-one is judging here Bree! So thrilled you enjoyed this one.

Cheers, John
ps remember to follow us so you are the first to hear about our new releases or special offers.

Like 9 months ago
Richard Silberstein Angel

10 months ago

loved the Montvalley Hunter Valley Reserve Semillon 2022. going back for more.

(latest reply 10 months ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

We are thrilled our angels are loving this one - thanks for your review Richard.

Cheers, John

Like 10 months ago
Richard Silberstein Angel

Hi John, unfortunately there was no more to be had.

Like 10 months ago
Karen Mulherin Angel

11 months ago

I'm not a massive Semillon fan but this was easy to drink. Clean and refreshing.

(latest reply 11 months ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

Thanks Karen - we might convert you to the Semillon side!!

Cheers, John

Like 11 months ago
Terence Bradford Angel

12 months ago

Was good

(latest reply 12 months ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

Thanks Terence - we are loving this one at the moment with fresh seafood on the BBQ.

So pleased you enjoyed it also.

Cheers, John
ps remember to follow us so you are the first to hear about our new releases or special offers.

Like 12 months ago
Lars Olofsson Angel

12 months ago

Abundance of lime, acidity, medium finish. Expected more structure from this Hunter varietal, but I assume that would probably come with some age.

(latest reply 12 months ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

Yes, absolutely Lars - pop it away for a few years and you'll watch is change dramatically in colour, flavour and complexity.

Cheers, John

Like 12 months ago
Peter Catt Angel

1 year ago

Clean, fruit-driven. Delicious on a still, humid summer evening

(latest reply 1 year ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

Thanks for the feedback Peter and so glad you enjoyed this one.

Cheers John
ps please remember to follow us so you are the first to hear about our new releases or special offers.

Like 1 year ago
Allison McPhee Angel

1 year ago

This was a delightful wine to drink.

(latest reply 1 year ago)
John Colvin Winemaker

Thanks Allison - we really appreciate your time in giving feedback. We think this one is a gem and it has plenty more time left in the bottle.

Cheers, John
ps remember to follow us so you are the first to hear about our new releases or special offers.

Like 1 year ago